2013 Results: 5-13; 5-4 HCAC
| Feb. 24-27 | Winter Break @ Orlando, Fla. | |
| Feb. 24 | vs. Davenport (Iowa) | 9-0 Loss |
| Feb. 25 | vs. Capital (Ohio) | 7-1 Loss |
| Feb. 26 | vs. Concordia (Minn.) | 8-1 Loss |
| vs. Augustana (Ill.) | 9-0 Loss | |
| Feb. 27 | vs. Alma (Mich.) | 6-3 Loss |
| March 16 | @ Wabash | 9-0 Loss |
| vs. Cornerstone (Mich.) @ Crawfordsville, Ind. | 7-2 Loss | |
| March 23 | Rose-Hulman * | 5-4 Loss |
| March 28 | Mount St. Joseph (Ohio) * | 8-1 Win |
| March 30 | Manchester * | 8-1 Win |
| April 1 | Brescia (Ky.) | 6-3 Loss |
| April 3 | Transylvania (Ky.) * | 8-1 Loss |
| April 6 | @ Anderson * | 8-1 Win |
| April 10 | vs. Earlham * @ Dayton, Ohio | 9-0 Loss |
| April 13 | Bluffton (Ohio) * | 9-0 Win |
| April 14 | @ Franklin * | 7-2 Loss |
| April 27 | @ Defiance (Ohio) * | 9-0 Win |
| May 4-5 | @ Heartland Conference Tournament @ Indianapolis, Ind. | |
| May 4 | vs. Rose-Hulman | 5-1 Loss |
2012 Results: 8-10; 4-5 HCAC
| Feb. 27 | vs. Alma (Mich.) @ Orlando, Fla. | 5-4 Win |
| Feb. 28 | vs. Augustana (Ill.) @ Orlando, Fla. | 8-1 Loss |
| vs. Capital (Ohio) @ Orlando, Fla. | 5-4 Loss | |
| Feb. 29 | vs. Concordia (Minn.) @ Orlando, Fla. | 5-4 Win |
| March 1 | vs. Wartburg (Iowa) | 8-1 Loss |
| March 10 | @ Manchester | 7-2 Win |
| March 17 | @ Wabash | 9-0 Loss |
| vs. Cornerstone (Mich.) @ Crawfordsville, Ind. | 7-2 Win | |
| March 21 | @ Mount St. Joseph (Ohio) | 6-3 Win |
| March 25 | Franklin | 5-4 Loss |
| March 31 - April 1 | Wabash Invitational | Results |
| April 2 | Oakland City | 5-4 Win |
| April 7 | Anderson | 6-3 Loss |
| April 9 | @ Transylvania | 5-4 Loss |
| April 11 | Earlham | 9-0 Loss |
| April 14 | @ Bluffton (Ohio | 9-0 Win |
| April 28 | Defiance (Ohio) | 5-2 Win |
| April 29 | @ Rose-Hulman | 5-4 Loss |
| May 5-6 | Heartland Conference Tournament @ Indianapolis, Ind. | |
| May 5 | vs. Franklin | 5-1 Loss |
2011 Results: 7-7; 3-4 HCAC
| Feb. 13 | Rose-Hulman* @ Indianapolis, Ind. | 9-0 Loss |
| Feb. 27-March 3 | Winter Break Trip - Orlando, Fla. | |
| Feb. 27 | vs. Alma (Mich.) @ Lake Cane | 6-3 Loss |
| Feb. 28 | vs. Capital (Ohio) @ Star Island | 7-2 Win |
| March 2 | vs. Wartburg (Iowa) @ Lake Cane | 5-4 Win |
| March 3 | vs. Augustana (Ill.) @ Lake Cane | 9-0 Loss |
| March 12 | @ Mount St. Joseph (Ohio)* | 8-1 Win |
| March 19 | @ Defiance (Ohio)* | 8-1 Win |
| March 20 | Miami-Hamilton (Ohio) | 8-1 Win |
| March 26-27 | @ Wabash Tourney | Results |
| April 5 | Mount St. Joseph (Ohio) | 6-3 Win |
| April 6 | Transylvania (Ky.)* | 8-1 Loss |
| April 9 | vs. Anderson @ Earlham* | 6-3 Loss |
| April 17 | Manchester* | 8-1 Win |
| Franklin* | 5-4 Loss | |
| April 30-May 1 | HCAC Tournament @ Indianapolis, Ind. | |
| April 30 | vs. Earlham | 5-0 Loss |
* denotes Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference matches
2010 Results: 10-7; 5-2 HCAC
| Feb. 27-March 2 | Winter Break Trip - Orlando, Fla. | |
| Feb. 28 | vs. Alma (Mich.) | 5-4 Loss |
| March 1 | vs. Notre Dame (Ohio) | 5-4 Loss |
| March 2 | vs. Ohio Northern | 7-2 Loss |
| vs. Mount St. Mary (Md.) | 9-0 Loss | |
| March 16 | Mount St. Joseph (Ohio)* | 9-0 Win |
| March 20 | Defiance (Ohio)* | 5-4 Win |
| Rose-Hulman* | 5-3 Loss | |
| March 24 | Thomas More (Ky.) | 9-0 Win |
| March 26 | vs. Anderson* @ Indianapolis, Ind. | 8-1 Win |
| March 27-28 | @ Wabash Tournament | Results |
| March 30 | @ Mount St. Joseph (Ohio) | 5-0 Win |
| April 7 | @ Transylvania (Ky.)* | 5-0 Loss |
| April 10 | @ Franklin* | 5-2 Win |
| vs. Manchester* | 5-0 Win | |
| April 11 | @ Miami-Hamilton (Ohio) | 5-0 Win |
| April 14 | @ Miami-Middletown (Ohio) | 6-1 Win |
| May 1-2 | @ Heartland Conference Tournament @ Indianapolis, Ind. | |
| May 1 | vs. Anderson | 5-3 Win |
| May 2 | vs. Rose-Hulman (semifinals) | 5-2 Loss |
* denotes Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference matches
2009 Results: 7-6; 4-3 HCAC
| Feb. 22 | vs. Capital (Ohio) @ Orlando, Fla. | 5-4 Win |
| Feb. 23 | vs. Alma (Mich.) @ Orlando, Fla. | 8-1 Loss |
| Feb. 23 | vs. Brandeis (Mass.) @ Orlando, Fla. | 8-1 Loss |
| March 5 | @ Mount St Joseph (Ohio)* | 6-0 Win |
| March 14 | Bluffton (Ohio)* | 9-0 Win |
| March 14 | Anderson* | 5-4 Win |
| March 19 | Miami-Hamilton (Ohio) | 9-0 Win |
| March 21 | @ Manchester* | 9-0 Win |
| March 28-29 | @ Wabash Tournament | Results |
| April 4 | @ Rose-Hulman* | 5-0 Loss |
| vs Defiance (Ohio)* | 5-2 Loss | |
| April 9 | Mount St Joseph (Ohio) | 9-0 Win |
| April 29 | Transylvania (Ky.)* | 5-0 Loss |
| May 2-3 | at Heartland Conference Tournament @ Indianapolis, Ind. | |
| May 2 | vs. Franklin | 6-3 Loss |
* denotes Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference matches