| Year | Name | Subject |
|---|---|---|
| 1969 | Harve Rawson | psychology |
| 1970 | Robert Bowers | history |
| 1971 | John Yarnelle | math |
| 1972 | John Matthews | theology |
| 1973 | Richard Conklin | physics |
| 1974 | George Zirkle | psychology |
| 1975 | Paul Blume | economics |
| 1976 | Robert Keller | sociology |
| 1977 | Jan Smucker | philosophy |
| 1978 | John Matthews | theology |
| 1979 | Richard Conklin | physics |
| 1980 | Harve Rawson | psychology |
| 1981 | William Dunham | math |
| 1982 | James Maysilles | botany |
| 1983 | Ray Webster | physical education |
| 1984 | George Curtis | history |
| 1985 | Larry Joe Moore | economics |
| 1986 | Penny Dunham | math |
| 1987 | Barbara Garvey | communication |
| 1988 | Paul Blume | economics |
| 1989 | George Curtis | history |
| 1990 | Jan Smucker | philosophy |
| 1991 | Larry Thornton | history |
| 1992 | John Thomas | art |
| 1993 | Marsha Dutton | English |
| 1994 | George Curtis | history |
| 1995 | Phil Barlow | theology |
| 1996 | Cliff Fisher | economics |
| 1997 | Kathy Barbour/Dee Goertz | English |
| 1998 | Marsha Dutton | English |
| 1999 | Kate Johnson | philosophy |
| 2000 | Nancy Hanna | psychology |
| 2001 | Phil Barlow | theology |
| 2002 | Walter Bruyninckx | biology |
| 2003 | David Buchman | anthropology |
| 2004 | Larry Thornton | history |
| 2005 | Don Carrel | philosophy |
| 2006 | Dave Cassel | theology |
| 2007 | Darrin Rubino | biology |
| 2008 | Bill Bettler | communication |
| 2009 | Kathy Barbour | English |
| 2010 | Don Carrel | philosophy |
| 2011 | Jim Crone | sociology |
| 2012 | Darrin Rubino | biology |